| RETAIL STORE: 8 AM - 6 PM DAILY  | CAFÉ BUILDING:  FRI & SAT 8 AM - 6 PM / 8 AM - 4 PM SU & M & TH / CLOSED ON TUES & WED | BREAKFAST: 8 AM - 10:30 AM | LUNCH: 11 AM - 3 PM / Till 4 on SAT | MAIL ORDER: 9 AM - 5 PM DAILY | All time in EST |

Cold Hollow - Thumbprint Cookies

Description

This classic cookie is made even tastier by the old country kitchen trick of filling a thumbprint with something special - in this case, our own famous Cider Jelly - before cooking. The sweetly delicious result has become a favorite in our store and is now available through our catalog. Each box comes with 12 irresistible 2" cookies. A holiday season essential that's just as good on the Fourth of July.

Product form

$9.95

  • Orders are typically processed and shipped within 48 hours.
  • Many of our items are perishable and must ship via Express or Priority Mail.

    Description

    This classic cookie is made even tastier by the old country kitchen trick of filling a thumbprint with something special - in this case, our own famous Cider Jelly - before cooking. The sweetly delicious result has become a favorite in our store and is now available through our catalog. Each box comes with 12 irresistible 2" cookies. A holiday season essential that's just as good on the Fourth of July.

    Customer Reviews

    Based on 12 reviews
    83%
    (10)
    8%
    (1)
    8%
    (1)
    0%
    (0)
    0%
    (0)
    T
    Tester
    Num Num

    My go to snack cookie. Not sure if the actual cookie sans the center treat is a butter or shortbread. Whatever, it darn tasty.

    A
    Anna Wys
    Best cookies ever!

    These cookies are so buttery tasting and moist. The apple cider jelly complements the cookie perfectly. I love these cookies. Every bakery product that I've ordered has been excellent! You should definitely give these a try. You can taste that they use only the highest quality ingredients.

    J
    Janet Walsh
    Yum

    I love these cookies….for many years, I’ve made holiday gift boxes for friends and the staff at my local bank, library and post office which consist mainly of these thumbprint cookies with some of the maple leaf shortbread cookies mixed in.
    Whatever doesn’t fit in the gift boxes, I get to devour.

    G
    Gail Goldsmith
    DELICIOUS!

    Sent cookies to a friend and she couldn't stop raving about them!

    C
    Carolyn Blakley
    Thumbs Up!

    Your Cider Jelly Thumbprint Cookies are the best! They were fresh, delicious, and the combination of jelly with the shortbread cookie was perfect. Will definitely order again.

    Recently viewed products

      Footer image

      © 2025 Cold Hollow Cider Mill, Powered by Shopify

        • American Express
        • Apple Pay
        • Diners Club
        • Discover
        • Google Pay
        • Mastercard
        • Shop Pay
        • Visa

        Login

        Forgot your password?

        Don't have an account yet?
        Create account